Embodying a right to health care

In a residency applicant’s personal statement, I came across this sentence about a doctor working among impoverished rural people: “His presence embodies their equal right to health care.”

Equal right to health care. When speaking about rights, I always hear that one person’s positive right implies an obligation on somebody else’s part to provide something. For instance, one person’s right to health care implies that somebody else has an obligation to provide that care.

The applicant’s quote turns this idea on its head. Our system and government do not recognize a right to health care. But by his presence, the doctor is a witness that, although these people might not be able to pay for health care, these people are valuable, they deserve health care, and he will provide it. The doctor’s presence embodies what our system and government do not acknowledge.

The presence of health care-ers in the most difficult and impoverished and hopeless corners of our society is the testimony that, since the doctor has the obligation to care for all who are patients, everyone has a right to health care. Since, in this country, the right to health care is not guaranteed by our system or our laws, it must be guaranteed by us (I write as a physician), by individuals and groups of care-ers, doctors and nurses and PAs and NPs and therapists who enact others’ right to health care by caring. Our self-acknowledged obligation to care for the sick wordlessly, but eloquently, proclaims that all those whom we serve have an equal right to health care.

Maybe someday the system will catch up.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Carol J. Eblen
Carol J. Eblen
5 years ago

It is my understanding that over half of the physicians in the United States favor a single payer system wherein the profit motive will be “tamed” and all of our citizens will have access to health care.

If only these numbers would grow and the AMA, itself, would lobby for a “single payer” system. But, of course, the power of money and the love of money presents a huge obstacle to any kind of universal health care program in the USA.

Big insurance has invaded the people’s social safety nets that are fed with SS taxes, Medicare Taxes, and state taxes that Americans pay all of their working lives. Big Insurance realizes obscene profits whether as public companies or so called non-profits. Our Congress, both political parties, have surrendered to the power of the big money and its influence.

The system will never catch up until enough of those in medicine and within the system tell the truth to the people about the “rape” of the public purse by those who treat “patients” as “product” for profit and who let the good physicians do charity work, as they can.

We should be ashamed that our country, supposedly the wealthiest and most powerful in the world, doesn’t consider health care a human right and a civil right of its citizens. How can we call ourselves Christians if we stand by and continue to sanction the “for profit” system?