The limits of medicine and technology

 

In Too Much to Know, author Ann Blair notes that in our culture, which virtually deifies technology, we believe that we can find technological solutions to all problems, even those that are actually addressable only by attending to ourselves.*

Perhaps this confusion about the proper solution to a problem is part of the crisis in medicine and bioethics. The knee-jerk expectation of the public and the medical enterprise alike is that for every problem people bring before a doctor there can be found a solution, and that a technical solution will be the best. But what if that assumption is incorrect?

What if there are some patients for whom a technical solution is the worse option? Maybe there are some depressed patients for whom the best solution to their problem is not another pill, but the balm of human compassion and the encouragement to use the resources they have at hand to find comfort. Maybe there are some people with terminal diseases for whom the best solution is not every last possible intervention trying to sustain bodily function indefinitely, but rather help in strengthening faith and preparing for death.

Maybe instead of attempting to eliminate disabilities by trying to detect and eliminate fetuses that have them, we should be striving to be a people who can love and cherish those among us with worse disabilities than our own. Maybe instead of seeking absolute certainty (an illusion at best) by demanding that every technological test and scan be made available, we should be learning to live in the freedom of the inevitable uncertainty that comes with life on this planet.

Maybe there are types of human suffering that medicine was never meant to address. Maybe there are problems that we can only address by fixing not the problem, but our selves. And maybe part of the task of bioethics should be seeking the wisdom to discern between the two.

 

*This summary of Blair’s thought is from Alan Jacobs’s review in the May/June 2011 Books & Culture.

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
  Subscribe  
Notify of